Facilitator Journal | Issue #0410, September 22, 2009
Facilitation is all about collaboration, yet our cultural programming contains strong themes of competition for notoriety or for limited resources. Thankfully today, there seems to be a growing interest in collaboration in many facets of society. In this week's article, Recognizing Barriers to Collaboration,we explore several societal norms that impede collaborative work and tips for overcoming them.
Facilitating at a Distance coming September 28th: Essentials of Teleclass & Virtual Meeting Facilitation. This class is for those of you wanting to offer a teleclass but don't feel you have all the skills and knowledge you need to do so, or for managers working with distributed teams that require you to facilitate virtual meetings. See details at the end of this issue.
Journey of Facilitation and Collaboration Workshop. We'll be breaking the ice (literally) on our next Journey of Facilitation and Collaboration Workshop the week of January 11th in Madison Wisconsin...check out this opportunity to learn an Integrally Informed Approach to Facilitation and Leadership. Click here for details and registration. We find that a sufficiently large huddle at this workshop helps keep us all warm at this time of year in Madison!
Recognizing Barriers to Collaboration
Know the habits and attitudes that impede collaboration.
Group Process Skill
Madness is rare in individuals--but in groups, parties, nations, and ages, it is the rule.
—Friedrich Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil—
We hear so much about what it takes to compete, but what does it take to collaborate? And while there's a growing need for true collaboration in our society, locally and globally, just what does it mean to collaborate?
Collaboration involves two or more people coming together to share their collective knowledge, experience, and creativity to arrive at a shared understanding or tangible outcome that none of the individuals could have arrived at on their own. Collaboration is more complex than teamwork, which tends to operate in a sequential fashion to accomplish tasks or to join together to defend against outside forces.
I like what Michael Schrage of MIT has to say about collaboration “…[collaboration is about] the creation of value; a process that our traditional structures of communication and teamwork can’t achieve.”
Today, I'd like to take an unusual approach to exploring collaboration. I'd like to look at what stands in its way. If we are to teach a fish to fly, we must first show it the water that it depends upon. Because this water has surrounded the fish all of its life, it is probably unaware of it.
Just as the fish may be clueless about the water in which it swims, there are streams of behavior and belief through which we unwittingly travel that stand in the way of us effectively collaborating. What are they? I share my take on them below. In the spirit of true collaboration, share yours as well and we’ll build on this list.
Failure to recognize the complexity of group thought. When we think that communicating and producing outcomes en masse should be just as easy as doing so individually, we tend to negatively judge the slower pace and additional processes required for collaborative activity. These judgments of ourselves, or others cloud and impede our work together. The first step toward effective collaboration requires us to be patient with the process, expecting that while working with a group will be slower and more difficult than working on our own, our outcomes will be worth the investment.
Commingling of task and process. Groupwork is often confused when we avoid separating discussions of task (the group goal), and process (how the group will complete its goal). Discussing process is confusing if done before the task is clear. Yet in this high-speed world, we’re all called upon to do less with more and charge off to “get it done” quickly. When groups don't get clear about what “it” is, they aren't focused on the same objective, and they can't collaborate. Get a clear consensus on task before pursuing it to get your collaborations off to the right start.
Multifocusing. As individuals, we can attend to only one item at a time. Groups can multifocus and this capacity can make it very difficult for all individuals to track what’s going on. This is why effective collaboration requires that all relevant inputs are heard by everyone and recorded for all to see.
Serial communication. Accustomed to simple one-on-one conversations, in groups we tend to listen to others share stories, information or opinions, until a space opens up for us to do the same. What we share doesn’t always connect to what others have said. And seldom do we check to make sure we really understood what was said. This self-centered style of delivering messages does not contribute to a shared understanding, the hallmark of collaboration.
Computer networks that engage in serial communication do something called “handshaking.” After receiving a message, the receiving terminal replies to the transmitting terminal to let it know the message was received and checks the accuracy of what was received. We’d do well to emulate this process in our human “networking” activities more often.
The loudest and fastest get the floor. The most outspoken and quickest thinkers often dominate group discussion. While their inputs may be valuable, they don’t represent all of what the group has to say and often not the best of what the group has to offer. Once again, to effectively collaborate, we must see to it that multiple methods are in place to invite and capture all relevant inputs.
People need to be heard. Many of us felt ignored as children and have a need as adults to make our voices heard in groups. Individuals speaking only to meet their own needs will tax the patience and emotional energy of a group. Challenge participants to speak when moved to speak. Also ask them to perform a self-check before speaking by asking themselves whether what they have to say is relevant, positive, and necessary to the group's objectives.
Addicted to consistency. People dislike inconsistency and will attempt to eliminate it. When mental conflict occurs because beliefs or assumptions are contradicted by new information, people will tend to suppress, rationalize, avoid, or oversimplify it away. Help people to hang in there when mentally challenged by new ways of seeing things. Remind them that in order to arrive at a solution that fits with reality, they must be willing to face the full complexity of the situation. Facing complexity can be challenging and facing it as a group, they don’t have to do it alone.
Distractions and Disassociation. Every group encounters distractions from the late arrivals and early departures, to uncomfortable surroundings, to telephone interruptions, poor technical facilities, etc. The coupling of distractions with the difficulty of group thinking causes individuals to disassociate from the task at times to take a mental break. All participants tend to wander from time to time resulting in a short circuit of the group mind. Presume you are losing some members all of the time and regularly summarize and document the status of the discussion.
I'm sure there are more barriers to collaboration in the attitudes, behaviors, and beliefs that we consider "normal" in our society. Keep your eyes, ears, and hearts open as you traverse the collaborative landscape, looking for ways to point out and heal these barriers in your group work.
What do you see as norms or habits of human behavior that stand in the way of collaboration? Send in your ideas. I'll integrate them into this article and repost it for you to refer to online. Please reply to this email and share
your comments. I'd love to hear from you.
This Week's Offer
at a Distance Teleclass...
The Essentials of
Virtual Meeting Facilitation
you considered offering a teleclass as a more efficient
way to deliver training, enhance group learning
and generate more income for your business? Or,
are you working with a distributed team that requires
you to design and facilitate virtual meetings?
done right, Teleclasses and Virtual Meetings (T/VM)
are very effective and inexpensive ways to train,
collaborate, and problem-solve. But if they aren't
effectively facilitated, T/VM's can be a boring
waste of time!
the fear and uncertainty of teleclass/virtual meeting
design and facilitation with this 5-day teleclass
series: Leading at a Distance: The Essentials
of Teleclass & Virtual Meeting Facilitation,
led by Steve Davis, Founder of FacilitatorU.com,
September 28th-October 2nd, 2009, 10:00 AM Pacific, 1:00 PM Eastern
60 minutes each day.
This class covers all the elements of T/VM facilitation
using a simple, well-organized, and proven approach.
This course, that you can take from the comfort
of your own home or office, is for facilitators,
trainers, coaches, who want to design relevant,
engaging, experiential workshops for groups using
a simple, proven formula that's easy to apply to
any workshop topic.
Learn how to design and run a T/VM that will maximize
the use of your group's time and energy.
the end of the 5 days, you will:
learned the key skills needed to effectively
facilitate a Teleclass/Virtual Meeting.Know
how to balance interactivity with meeting
purpose. Become familiar with the 10 modes of delivering
learning and information in a virtual environment.Know mistakes to avoid when facilitating your
the 7 Keys to the Inner Game of T/VM Facilitation.
Click here for full details and registration
Become a FacilitatorU.com Premium member and register for
this teleclass at half price in addition to a host of other items and
benefits. An exceptional value. Click
here for details.
If, for any reason, you are not satisfied with this package, simply
email us with a request to refund/credit your credit card in the full
amount and we will do so immediately. This policy completely removes the
buying risk for you and keeps our customer-satisfaction rates extremely
About the satisfaction